|
al-Sabzawari,
al-Hajj Mulla Hadi (1797/8-1873)
al-Sabzawari, al-Hajj Mulla Hadi (1797/8-1873) Al-Sabzawari
was the most influential
nineteenth-century Iranian
philosopher. His reputation rests in
part on his Sharh al-manzuma, a
commentary on his own Ghurar al-fara’id
(The Blazes of the Gems), a didactic
poem (manzuma) encapsulating in a
systematic fashion an exposition of
the existentialist philosophy of
Mulla Sadra. He was also the most
sought-after teacher of philosophy
in his day, and many students
travelled to Sabzavar to be taught
by him. Famous for his saintliness
as well as his erudition, he set the
tone for much of twentieth-century
Iranian philosophy. Al-Hajj Mulla
Hadi al-Sabzawari, the most famous
of the philosophers of the Qajar
period in Iran, was born in AH
1212/AD 1797-8 in Sabzavar in
northeastern Iran. He studied logic,
mathematics, law and metaphysics in
Mashhad, where he moved at the age
of ten after completing his
preliminary education in Sabzavar.
He pursued his interests in
philosophy by moving to Isfahan to
study for seven years with, among
others, Mulla ‘Ali Nuri (d. AH
1246/AD 1830-1), the foremost
interpreter of his day of the
philosophy of Mulla Sadra. He
returned to Mashhad to teach for
five years, and then accomplished
the pilgrimage to Mecca (hajj). On
his way back from pilgrimage he
spent a year in Kirman, where he
married, before returning to
Sabzavar where he spent the rest of
his life devoted to teaching and
writing. A remarkable number of
students of philosophy came to study
with him, not only from Iran but
from Arab countries and India as
well. So great was his reputation
that Nasir al-Din Shah, for whom he
wrote his Asrar al-hikam (Secrets of
the Wisdoms), came to visit him in
AH 1284/AD 1867, but al-Sabzawari’s
pious and ascetic way of life
(several minor miracles are
attributed to him), led him to
refuse direct royal patronage. He
died in AH 1289/AD 1873, having
turned Mulla Sadra’s legacy into
the predominant philosophical school
of the nineteenth and twentieth
centuries. Al-Sabzawari’s fame
rests primarily on one work, his
Ghurar al-fara’id (The Blazes of
the Gems), a poem in which he gives
a systematic and complete
presentation of the philosophy of
the school of Mulla Sadra, together
with the Sharh al-manzuma, his own
commentary on this poem, which he
composed despairing of the
philosophical ignorance of his
contemporaries. The merit of this
work lies not so much in any
radically new theories, but in its
plan and organization, which have
made it the standard text for
students of philosophy in Shi‘i
madrasas until the present day. The
situation is now changing and new
teaching texts are appearing, but
most of these are still influenced
by the Sharh al-manzuma in both
structure and content. In the
centuries after Mulla Sadra,
philosophers were on the whole
inclined to write on specific
topics, thus leaving a gap in so far
as there was no text that treated
the whole of post-Sadrian philosophy
in a systematic and assimilable
fashion to which students could
turn. Al-Sabzawari filled this gap,
first with his didactic poem, which
was to be memorized, and second with
his commentary, which elaborates the
poem in the manner of a traditional
teacher in the Islamic religious
sciences. The completeness of the
work can be gauged by its contents,
which give a good idea of what
subjects philosophy encompasses for
the contemporary religious student
in a Shi‘i madrasa.The first part
is on logic, with the commentary
separately subtitled al-La’ali al-muntazima
(The Well-Ordered Nights). The
second part (with commentary
subtitled Ghurar al-fara’id), is
divided into seven sections: (1)
general principles (al-umur al-‘amma),
covering existence and related
matters (unity, systematic
ambiguity, modality, actuality and
so on), quiddity and causality; (2)
substance and accident; (3)
metaphysical theology (al-ilahiyyat
bi-’l-ma‘na al-akhass), God’s
essence, attributes and acts; (4)
natural philosophy, including
discussions of matter and motion and
a section on psychology;
(5) certain supernatural
phenomena, including reams, miracles
and prophecy; (6) the resurrection (ma‘ad);
and (7) ethics (akhlaq), with a
brief treatment of spiritual values.
It should be noted that (2) is
essentially part of (1), that (1-4)
form the core of the work, and that
(5-7) are relatively short sections.
The commentary is amply provided
with proofs and arguments, but there
is also a marked emphasis on
intuitive and mystical perception.
This aspect of al-Sabzawari’s
thought is even more evident in his
other works, which included
commentaries on two of the key
supplications in Shi‘I devotional
literature and the above-mentioned
Asrar al-hikam, in Persian, in which
eschatology is elucidated through
metaphysical theology, psychology,
ethics and the law (shari‘a). This
latter work is threaded through with
poetic quotations. Al-Sabzawari was
not only a poet in his own right (he
has a Persian diwan, or collection
of poems), but he also produced an
elaborate metaphysical commentary on
passages from Jalal al-Din al-Rumi’s
Mathnavi which amply reflects his
own spiritual preoccupations.
Because of the elegance of his
exposition of the entire scope of
the Sadrian philosophy of his time,
al-Sabzawari has attracted the
attention of a number of modern
scholars who, under the influence of
his manifestly esoteric outlook,
have tended to emphasize the
mystical approach in
nineteenth-century Iranian
philosophy. Although this influence
has tended to obscure other
philosophical currents of the time
and their legacy to
twentieth-century Iranian
philosophy, it cannot be denied that
al-Sabzawari was the most
significant philosopher of this
period and the one who, through the
large number of his students,
exerted the most powerful effect on
later generations. See also: Islamic
philosophy, modern; Mulla Sadra;
Mystical philosophy in Islam JOHN
COOPER
Routledge Encyclopedia of
Philosophy, Version 1.0, London:
Routledge
List of works
In addition to the works listed below, al-Sabzawari
wrote glosses on several works by
Mulla Sadra. Those on the Asfar can
be found in the footnotes of the
printed edition of that work (see
Mulla Sadra). al-Sabzawari (1826-45)
Sharh al-manzuma (commentary on the
didactic poem (manzuma), the Ghurar
al-fara’id), ed. H.H. al-Amuli and
M. Talibi, Tehran: Nab, 1995, 3 vols;
Sharh-I manzuma, lithograph editions
in Arabic.(This edition is so far
incomplete. The only complete text
is provided by numerous printings of
the lithographed texts, the most
common being the so-called
‘Nasiri’ lithograph. In the
published edition, Volume 1 contains
the logic, al-La’ali al-muntazima;
Volume 2 is sections 1 and 2 of the
metaphysics of the Ghurar al-fara’id;
Volume 3 contains the remainder of
the metaphysics. The text is in
Arabic with glosses by H.H. al-Amuli,
but there is an English introduction
to Volume 3. An earlier Arabic
edition of the metaphysics is Sharh
ghurar al-fara’id, ed. M.
Mohaghegh and T. Izutsu, Tehran:
McGill University Institute of
Islamic Studies, Tehran Branch,
1969. This edition also contains
extracts from the commentaries of
Muhammad Taqi Amuli and Akhund-e
Hidaji, and has a useful
Arabic-English glossary of al-Sabzawari’s
philosophical terminology.) al-Sabzawari
(1867-70) Asrar al-hikam (Secrets of
the Wisdoms), ed. H.M. Farzad,
Tehran: Intisharat-e Mawla,
1982.(Arabic text, not a critical
edition.) References and further
reading Akhtar, W. (1984)
‘Sabzawari’s Analysis of
Being’, al-Tawhid 2 (1):
29-65.(Makes a strong case for
Sabzawari’s originality as a
thinker, and situates the Sharh al-manzuma
within a history of ontology; useful
comparative analysis.) Izutsu
Toshihiko (1971) ‘The Fundamental
Structure of Sabzawari’s
Metaphysics’, in Izutsu Toshihiko
(ed.) The Concept and Reality of
Existence, Tokyo: Keio Institute of
Cultural andLinguistic Studies,
57-149.(A discussion of existence
and quiddity in peripatetic and
illuminationist philosophy, as the
background to understanding al-Sabzawari’s
thought.) Izutsu Toshihiko and
Mohaghegh, M. (1983) The Metaphysics
of Sabzawari, Delmar, NY:
Caravan.(An English translation of
the first section of the Ghurar al-fara’id.)
Nasr, S.H. (1966) ‘Renaissance in
Iran (continued): Haji Mulla Hadi
Sabziwari’, in M.M. Sharif (ed.) A
History of Muslim Philosophy,
Wiesbaden: Harrasowitz; repr.
Karachi, 1983. (A good introduction
to the content of al-Sabzawari’s
Sharh al-manzuma.)
Routledge Encyclopedia of
Philosophy, Version 1.0, London:
Routledge
|